New Jersey

Court Orders Temporary Halt to Controversial New Jersey Dune Project

Officials say preliminary test results revealed elevated levels of bacteria in the water which has been extremely slow to drain into the sand after five inches of rain fell over the weekend.

The Superior Court of New Jersey ruled Thursday to temporarily halt work on a dune construction project which has caused controversy in the South Jersey shore town of Margate. 

Construction of dunes on the Margate beach is now on hold until at least Aug. 11. There will be another hearing between all parties discussing how to solve the beach's drainage issues on that day.  

Margate is now again wading into what has been a costly and thus far futile court battle against Army Corps of Engineers-built sand dunes. Huge bacteria-laden ponds formed along blocks of the beach, blocking access to the shore in numerous spots, after an especially drenching storm over the weekend.

Officials in Margate, just south of Atlantic City, voted Wednesday to seek a court injunction to halt half-finished dune work that so far has created ponds of standing water.

The work is part of a statewide effort to protect New Jersey's 127-mile coastline following the devastation that Superstorm Sandy caused in 2012. But Margate residents say their Sandy damage came mostly from the town's bay side, not oceanside.

And in years of opposition and lawsuits trying to block the project before it started, Margate officials and homeowners argued the dunes would just trap water up against a wooden bulkhead at the sand's edge.

When weekend storms dumped a half-foot of water on Margate, that's exactly what happened.

"'I told you so' is not a good feeling," said Margate Commissioner Maury Blumberg. "There's nothing more important to Margate than its beaches, and this project is killing us. My hope is that tomorrow this project is stopped dead in its tracks."

The three-member city commission voted unanimously to hire a law firm to seek a court injunction halting the dune project until an adequate drainage system can be devised.

Mayor Michael Becker said state and federal officials have floated the idea of installing outfall pipes from the beach to the ocean at a cost of $10 million.

"I want this project stopped immediately," he said earlier in the week. "We are suffering irreparable harm having it here."

After the storms, three pools of water formed behind the dunes, some of them 2 feet deep or more. Days after state and federal engineers promised the water would have drained away, the water is still there, forcing grumbling residents to make blocks-long detours.

The Army Corps on Tuesday started pumping the water over the dunes as a short-term fix, and much of the water had been removed by midday Wednesday. But Margate officials were still concerned about the toxic brew of contaminants being sent into the ocean, where, despite the obstacles to reach the beach, some swimmers continued to enter the water all week.

"They're pumping contaminated water into the ocean," Abbott said. "If a private individual did that, they'd be fined, if not jailed."

Patti Deroo has an oceanfront house that her family built decades ago that is near one of the ponds.

"A new lawsuit needs to be filed," she said. "The city and the homeowners all said this was going to happen. Raising the bulkhead by six feet, now that would have made sense.

"The destruction of our beaches is incomprehensible," she said. "And they don't care. I actually feel physically ill from this. It's so upsetting."

Copyright AP - Associated Press
Contact Us