Judge Refers Theft Allegations Against Uber to US Attorney - NBC 10 Philadelphia
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Judge Refers Theft Allegations Against Uber to US Attorney

The high-stakes corporate espionage case revolves around Waymo's allegations that Uber's work on self-driving cars has been riding on trade secrets stolen by a former Google engineer

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Judge Refers Theft Allegations Against Uber to US Attorney
    AP
    In this Monday, Sept. 12, 2016, file photo, a self-driving Uber sits ready to take journalists for a ride during a media preview in Pittsburgh.

    A federal judge has referred trade secret theft allegations made against Uber by Google's autonomous car unit to the U.S. Attorney's office for investigation. 

    District Judge William Alsup in San Francisco made the referral in an order posted Thursday night. 

    Waymo has sued Uber alleging that the ride-hailing company is using stolen Waymo technology to develop its own self-driving vehicles. Alsup is presiding over the lawsuit. 

    "This case is referred to the United States Attorney for investigation of possible theft of trade secrets based on the evidentiary record supplied thus far concerning plaintiff Waymo LLC's claims for trade secret misappropriation," Alsup wrote in the order. "The court takes no position on whether a prosecution is or is not warranted, a decision entirely up to the United States Attorney." 

    3 Dead in Maryland Shooting; Manhunt for Gunman Underway

    [NATL] 3 Dead in Maryland Shooting; Manhunt for Gunman Underway

    Authorities are searching for Radee Labeeb Prince, 37, who is on the run after he was suspected of shooting five employees of Advanced Granite Solutions at the Emmorton Business Park in Edgewood, Maryland. 

    (Published 5 hours ago)

    Neither Uber nor Waymo would comment specifically on the judge's referral Thursday night. 

    The high-stakes corporate espionage case revolves around Waymo's allegations that Uber's work on self-driving cars has been riding on trade secrets stolen by a former Google engineer, Anthony Levandowski. 

    Waymo contends that before leaving Google early last year, Levandowski downloaded 14,000 documents containing details about a navigational tool called Lidar that robotic cars need to see what's around them. 

    Waymo has alleged in its lawsuit that Levandowski and Uber conspired to create a sham self-driving truck startup called Otto as a prelude to a $680 million deal for Uber to buy Otto and get the desperately needed technology. 

    After Uber bought Otto, Levandowski took over oversight of Uber's self-driving car division. He stepped down from the role earlier this month until Waymo's lawsuit is resolved. 

    Uber has vehemently denied using Waymo's ideas, maintaining that its Lidar system is radically different. Meanwhile, Levandowski has refused to turn over his personal laptop or answer most other questions posed by Waymo's lawyers while asserting his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. 

    US Gold Medalist Goes Public With Account of Sexual Abuse

    [NATL] US Gold Medalist Goes Public With Account of Sexual Abuse

    McKayla Maroney, a gold medalist and former Olympic gymnast, went public with her account of sexual assault by former US Gymnastics doctor Larry Nassar on Twitter. Maroney revealed she was assaulted for years by Nassar, beginning when she was 13 years old.

    (Published 6 hours ago)

    Also Thursday, Alsup issued a ruling on Waymo's request for an order to stop Uber's work on autonomous vehicles while the lawsuit is decided, but the ruling was temporarily sealed because it contained confidential information. A case synopsis said the judge granted part of Waymo's request but also denied part. 

    In addition, Alsup denied Uber's request to force the high-tech corporate espionage lawsuit out of court and into arbitration. Alsup ruled that Waymo has taken Levandowski to arbitration, and a separate lawsuit was the only course available to sue Uber. 

    In a statement, Waymo, part of Alphabet Inc., called Uber's arbitration request a "desperate bid" to avoid the court. "We welcome the court's decision today, and we look forward to holding Uber responsible in court for its misconduct," the statement said. 

    But Uber said it's unfortunate that Waymo can avoid an arbitration promise that it requires employees to make. "We remain confident in our case and welcome the chance to talk about our independently developed technology in any forum."