Judge Says Fired Inquirer Editor Must Be Reinstated

View Comments ()



    Bill Marimow returns to the Inquirer after a judge's ruling. But the battle between the newspaper's owners is far from over. NBC10's Daralene Jones was there as Marimow came back to work. (Published Friday, Nov 22, 2013)

    A judge has blocked the firing of Philadelphia Inquirer editor Bill Marimow amid a bitter dispute between rival owners ruling that he be reinstated immediately.

    Marimow's job status has brought the simmering private fight into public view, and prompted the feuding owners to sue each other.

    Rival co-owners George Norcross and Lewis Katz are both rich, powerful and accustomed to being in charge. Unless they ultimately find a way to work together, The Philadelphia Inquirer and Philadelphia Daily News could be sold for the sixth time in seven years, or the current ownership group could be reconfigured.

    Norcross is a Democratic powerbroker in southern New Jersey who built his wealth in the insurance industry. Katz made his fortune in parking lots, real estate and a stint owning the New Jersey Nets.

    Marimow Back as Editor of Inquirer

    [PHI] Marimow Back as Editor of Inquirer
    A judge has blocked the firing of Philadelphia Inquirer editor Bill Marimow. (Published Friday, Nov 22, 2013)

    Each pledged not to meddle in the newsroom when they bought equal 26 percent stakes of the company last year, for $16 million apiece. Four others bought lesser stakes. But Katz and Norcross control major decisions.

    Katz sued last month, accusing Norcross of trampling his voting rights by unilaterally firing Editor Bill Marimow. Norcross countersued. Common Pleas Judge Patricia McInerney, after hearing several days of testimony, did not immediately rule on Katz's request to block the firing.

    Katz and Norcross accuse each other of meddling in newsroom operations despite a non-interference pledge they took after buying the newspapers in April 2012. But the pledge seems almost doomed from the start. Both powerful businessmen have close ties inside the newsroom.

    Katz's longtime companion, veteran reporter Nancy Phillips, has become city editor. And Norcross' daughter came aboard to help oversee digital operations, including the Philly.com website.

    Phillips testified last week that she helped bring Marimow back to the Inquirer for a second term as editor, introducing him to Katz and Norcross. She said she also helped draft a cover story to suggest Marimow was hired by then-Publisher Greg Osberg. Osberg left weeks later.

    His successor, Bob Hall, fired Marimow last month. Katz, in his testimony, cast Hall as a highly-paid puppet who carries out Norcross's editorial agenda.

    "What's at stake is the independence of The Philadelphia Inquirer," Marimow lawyer Bill Chadwick said Wednesday.

    The company's board chairman, philanthropist H.F. "Gerry" Lenfest, testified that he invested $10 million as a civic gesture, only to watch Norcross wrest control of decisions large and small.

    "Everything is really done (under) the direction of Norcross," said Lenfest, who signed on to Katz's lawsuit.

    Norcross — who wielded most of his political power behind the scenes — was expected to testify Wednesday, but chose to stay off the stand. A spokesman for Norcross said late today that Norcross will appeal Marimow's reinstatement.

    "The decision to return Marimow to the Inquirer as a lame duck editor – his contract ends April 30th – will have the effect of risking chaos in the company, restoring an editor who consistently resisted needed changes to the paper and who is in open conflict with the Publisher, Bob Hall, who the court decreed will remain in his position. The ruling ensures that every newsroom decision will require the joint agreement of the Managing Members, subjecting the company to paralysis," said Dan Fee, the spokesman for Norcrosss and the majority owners.

    Katz's lawsuit seeks to return Marimow as editor and oust Hall on grounds that his contract has expired. The judge has declined to remove Hall, at least for now.

    Newsroom employees — including editors, reporters and photographers — have endured pay cuts, annual two-week furloughs and staff reductions as a series of owners have tried to turn the company around.

    The company's sale price has dropped from $515 million in 2006 to $139 million in a 2010 bankruptcy auction to $55 million last year.