“Screwed up” Breathalyzers Affect 1,000 DUI Cases

Police Commissioner Ramsey: "We screwed up"

Law enforcement officials in Philadelphia say more than a thousand drunk-driving cases could be affected by faulty breathalyzer tests because some of the department's machines were improperly calibrated.

"We screwed up, folks," Police Commissioner Charles Ramsey said at a news conference Wednesday. "We screwed up, plain and simple. And now we're paying for it."

Ramsey says a defense attorney discovered a discrepancy in test results last month and notified police.

Joe Kelly, a Defense Attorney who specializes in DUI cases says he discovered the bad breathalyzers.

“Anytime we defend somebody in a DUI case -- we ask for discovery in every case -- some of that discovery is accuracy and calibration of every machine,” Kelly said.

Ramsey and District Attorney Seth Williams say 1,147 DUI cases dating from September 2009 are now in doubt.

Some of Kelly clients are already challenging their rulings, Kelly said.

Williams says convicted defendants will be offered new trials but some of the cases will hold up because they're based on other factors, including blood tests.

A state police breath-test expert is checking the city's eight machines.

Ramsey says the faulty calibration was due to “human error.”

Fan, follow and download: Get the latest from NBCPhiladelphia.com anytime, anywhere. Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and NBC Philadelphia. Sign up for our breaking news newsletter. And, get breaking news delivered right to your mobile phone -- just text PHIBREAKING to 639710 to sign up. (Message and data rates may apply.)

Copyright AP - Associated Press
Contact Us