It came down to just three votes, the closest in history.
Pavel Datsyuk of the Red Wings took home the hardware with a vote of 945-942.
But wait, it gets better.
In partnership with NBC Sports Philadelphia
Richards had more first place votes (61) than Datsyuk (55). But, because Datsyuk had more overall support, the 30 year-old Russian walked out the winner.
Don't worry -- one Flyer did end up a winner at the NHL Awards, although it had nothing to do with his successes on the ice.
Hartnell went head-to-head and beat Canucks captain, and poker aficionado, Roberto Luongo.
Hartnell, a tournament poker newcomer, played down his win.
“I was lucky to get to the final two and I was lucky against Luongo there to win,” he said.
Lets hope he can bring that luck to ice next season.