Pennsylvania

Officer Who Used Stun Gun on Man in Viral Video Won't Be Suspended

Mayor Diane Sorace said Friday that the officer did not violate current use of force policies though those policies are being updated.

A police officer who shot a man with a stun gun in a viral video will not be suspended or fired, according to the mayor of Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

Mayor Diane Sorace said Friday that the officer did not violate current use of force policies though those policies are being updated.

Sorace says the new policy allows stun gun use only when an officer is "faced with direct physical confrontation.'' She says she was sorry for "the hurt, pain and turmoil this incident has caused for all involved.''

The decision came a few days after Sean Williams, the 27-year-old Lancaster man who was shot with the stun gun, filed a lawsuit against the officer as well as the Lancaster City Police Department.

The lawsuit accuses Lancaster Police Officer Philip Bernot of using excessive force and denying Williams' civil rights while also racially profiling him. 

Police say they were called to S. Prince Street around 10:15 a.m. on June 28 in Lancaster after a person reported that a man armed with a bat was chasing after three other people.

An officer who arrived at the scene says she saw three people telling a man, identified as Williams, to get away from them. The officer says she repeatedly told Williams to sit down but he didn’t listen. Williams kept telling a woman that he wanted her to give him his Social Security card, according to the officer.

A second officer, identified as Bernot, then arrived at the scene. It was at this point that a witness, Juan Almestica, began recording the encounter.

The video, which was posted on Facebook, shows Bernot instructing Williams to sit on a curb. Williams sits down and Bernot then repeatedly tells him to put his legs “straight out.” As Williams’ knees remain bent, Officer Bernot tells him “legs straight out or you’re getting tased.”

A second officer also tells him “put your legs straight out and cross them now.”

“This is done as a measure of control to insure that if someone is going to flee or offer physical resistance, they will have to move their legs under them to do so,” a Lancaster Police spokesperson wrote. “Non-compliance is often a precursor to someone that is preparing to flee or fight with Officers.”

Williams puts his legs out and then moves them back toward the curb. Officer Bernot then shoots him with a stun gun causing him to writhe on the ground in pain.

“You’re really gonna tase him? He was sitting down,” Almestica says.

The officers then order Williams to lie on his stomach and put his arms out. A total of four officers then gather around him, place him in handcuffs and take him into custody.

Almestica later told WGAL Williams may have been confused by the officers’ commands.

“He first put them straight and then she said cross your legs, so he tried to cross his legs, tased him in the back,” Almestica said. 

Police say a group of people claimed Williams had been acting erratically in the days prior to his arrest. The group said Williams had wanted to fight with them and was also trying to keep a woman from entering her apartment, according to police. However, contrary to the 911 call, the group also said they did not see Williams holding a bat and a bat was never found at the scene.

Williams had an outstanding criminal warrant for his arrest prior to Thursday’s incident, according to police. He was originally charged with possession of a controlled substance (PCP) and public drunkenness. 

Sean-Williams-Mugshot
Lancaster Police
Sean Williams

Williams was taken into custody on the outstanding warrant, transported to the station and checked by EMS, according to police. He was then cleared, arraigned and released on unsecured $5,000 bail.

Williams told WGAL he followed all the directions he was given and didn’t know why he was shot with the Taser.

The lawsuit disputes the Lancaster police report, claiming Williams was outside a friend's home when police arrived and that he had done nothing wrong. The lawsuit also states Williams complied with the officers and followed their orders but was stunned anyway.

Williams was held in police custody for several hours while in extreme pain, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit accuses officers of not offering him any medical attention or water. The lawsuit also states Williams continues to suffer severe head, neck, and shoulder pain as well as anxiety following the incident.

"Upon information and belief from publicly available sources, there is a clear racial disparity in Lancaster and the LPD has a history and pattern of intentionally discriminating against African Americans and other minorities," the lawsuit states.

The video of police tasing and arresting Williams went viral and sparked anger from some who believed the use of a stun gun was not necessary.

The video also prompted a response from Mayor Sorace prior to Friday's decision. Sorace posted a video on Facebook stating that an investigation was underway regarding the use of force in the incident. She also said the incident affirmed her resolve to implement a body camera program for Lancaster.

“We are currently awaiting word related to some federal grant funds from the Department of Justice related to funding and look forward to continuing to keep the public abreast of those developments as well as the outcome of this investigation,” she said.

Williams' attorney Brian Mildenberg said it was "outrageous" that the officer wasn't suspended.

Copyright AP - Associated Press
Contact Us