Brother of Johnny Doc Denies Benefiting From Alleged Stolen Union Funds

A Pennsylvania Supreme Court justice who is the younger brother of an indicted Philadelphia labor leader denied Thursday that he knowingly benefited from any money allegedly embezzled from the union.

The Philadelphia Inquirer cited five unidentified people familiar with the investigation as confirming Justice Kevin Dougherty is “family member No. 4” in court documents made public last week.

The 159-page federal indictment said union funds were used to pay to remove snow from the relative’s home in 2016, and for construction, repairs and painting there in 2011.

Dougherty’s lawyer told the newspaper he never knowingly accepted any improper benefits.

The judge, a Democrat elected in 2015, is not accused of wrongdoing in the indictment. His lawyer, Courtney Saleski, said he paid for all the work at his home and had no reason to know who shoveled his snow on the date in question.

Pennsylvania’s Republican Party issued a statement Thursday asking federal and state prosecutors and the court’s ethics boards to review the “serious matter.”

Dougherty’s brother, John Dougherty, is accused in an influence-peddling and embezzling case of misspending $600,000 in union funds for home repairs, sports tickets, trips and luxuries, and using union-funded benefits to illegally elicit official action from a Philadelphia city councilman.

He pleaded not guilty Friday.

John Dougherty has led the 5,000-member International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 98 since 1993 and more recently took the helm of the city’s Building Trades Council, which has 70,000 members.

Under him, the electricians’ union has become a major political campaign donor, spending more than $30 million through political action committees over the past decade to influence elections, campaign finance records show.

That includes about $1.5 million for Kevin Dougherty’s 2015 judicial campaign, or about one in three dollars the campaign reported spending, according to the records.

Republican Party of Pennsylvania Chairman Val DiGiorgio released a statement in response to the allegations against Dougherty.

“The fact that Justice Kevin Dougherty, a sitting Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice, received the same union-paid benefits his brother has been indicted for is a serious matter that raises a number of questions, like: Did Justice Dougherty knowingly request and/or accept these benefits? Was there any quid-pro-quo? Did Justice Dougherty properly disclose the receipt of these benefits? Did Justice Dougherty violate any ethical obligation if he failed to disclose the receipt of these benefits?

“We call on U.S. Attorney Bill McSwain, Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, the Judicial Conduct Board, and the Disciplinary Board of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to look further into these matters to ensure there is no fatal ethical taint on Justice Dougherty that would preclude him from carrying out the proper administration of justice in Pennsylvania.”