‘You're Playing With Fire If You Don't Report It.' What Happens If You Don't Disclose Crypto Activity This Tax Season

Jakub Porzycki | NurPhoto via Getty Images
  • There’s a question about “virtual currency” on the front page of your tax return, making it clear you need to disclose crypto activity. 
  • If you don’t report transactions and face an IRS audit, you may be hit with interest, penalties or even criminal charges.
  • “You’re playing with fire if you don’t report it,” said David Canedo, a CPA and tax specialist product manager at Accointing.

After recent market dips, reporting last year's cryptocurrency profits on your tax return may be less appealing. But hiding taxable activity may lead to IRS trouble, experts warn.

In 2021, the digital asset market sailed past $2 trillion, with bitcoin peaking at nearly $69,000 in November and ether growing to almost $5,000 during the same period. While values dropped in December, many investors still had sizable gains.  

And the IRS has made it clear they are watching with a yes or no question about "virtual currency" near the top of the first page of your tax return.     

"That's where the hammer comes down because they can say that you lied on a government document under penalties of perjury," said Ryan Losi, a Richmond, Virginia-based CPA and executive vice president of accounting firm PIASCIK. 

More from Advice and the Advisor:
Tax filing season kicks off. Here's how to get a faster refund
Your divorce may affect how much you receive from Social Security
Here’s how to navigate Medicare if you return to work after retiring

How crypto taxes work

Cryptocurrency may be subject to capital gains when exchanged or sold at a profit. Swapping digital coins, cashing out for U.S. dollars or even making a purchase may be taxable events, Losi explained.

The gain or loss is the difference between your purchase price, known as basis, and the value when selling or exchanging, and your tax rates depend on the length of ownership.

If you held digital assets for more than one year, you might qualify for long-term capital gains rates of 0%, 15% or 20%, depending on your taxable income.

However, many crypto investors sell or exchange more frequently, according to a CNBC survey, triggering short-term capital gains, levied at regular income tax rates, up to 37% for top earners.

What's worse, figuring out your basis to calculate your crypto tax bill may not be easy with limited reporting from digital currency exchanges.

What happens if you don't report taxable activity

If you don't report taxable crypto activity and face an IRS audit, you may incur interest, penalties, or even criminal charges.

It may be considered tax evasion or fraud, said David Canedo, a Milwaukee-based CPA and tax specialist product manager at Accointing, a crypto tracking and tax reporting tool.

While the chances of IRS scrutiny are lower with limited staffing, the agency may pursue larger amounts of money, he said. 

For example, there's a big difference between buying bitcoin in 2012 and cashing out millions of dollars in 2021 versus small trades for $100 profit, Canedo said. But you still have to disclose everything regardless. 

"You're playing with fire if you don't report it," he said.

Although the IRS has a three-year lookback for errors, there is no statute of limitations for fraud, Canedo said.

Another risk is whistleblowers, who can report missing activity to the IRS for a percentage of penalties collected, Losi from PIASCIK said.

"The number one way the IRS finds out about tax cheats is a former business partner or former spouse," he said.

Copyright CNBC
Contact Us