Search the Surgeon Scorecard Database - NBC 10 Philadelphia
Relentless pursuit of the truth

SEND TIPS610-949-7473

Search the Surgeon Scorecard Database



    Some Say State of Pa. Has Been 'Hoarding' Valuable Information About Surgeons

    We've been reporting on surgeons and their complication rates, as our media partner ProPublica created a first of its kind search engine that holds physicians accountable. NBC10's Mitch Blacher discovered Pennsylvania has been storing information for years. (Published Tuesday, July 28, 2015)

    Patients can now search to see how many complications a surgeon has had for certain Medicare reimbursed procedures. Our news partners at have been working on this information for three years. The nonprofit news organization looked at Medicare records from 2009 to 2013, noting surgical complications.

    The data includes more than sixty-four thousand medical problems — things like misaligned prosthetics, accidental punctures, infections, and deaths related to 8 kinds of elective surgeries. The complications are not necessarily caused by a surgeon, but they happen on the surgeon’s watch.

    ProPublica crunched the numbers and gave surgeons complication rates based on how many procedures they performed versus the number of complications.

    Using an algorithm, the group took into account risk factors like a patient’s age and health conditions, before coming up with what they call the adjusted complication rate.

    Patients Can Now See Local Surgeons' Complication Rates

    [PHI] Patients Can Now See Local Surgeons' Complication Rates
    Patients now have a new tool to find information on surgeons and the history of their complication rates. NBC10's Mitch Blacher searched records from our media partner ProPublica and has details about local physicians.
    (Published Tuesday, July 21, 2015)

    Some in the medical field question ProPublica’s findings, saying Medicare data only includes a fraction of hospital patients. Critics also point out there needs to be context to the information, including the patient’s socio-economic status.

    If you want to use the search engine, click here to get to ProPublica's website.