Year Later, Iran Nuclear Deal Is Holding But Fragile | NBC 10 Philadelphia
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Year Later, Iran Nuclear Deal Is Holding But Fragile

Upcoming elections in both the U.S. and Iran could yield new leaders determined to derail the deal



    In this Jan. 16, 2016, file-pool photo, Secretary of State John Kerry talks with Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif in Vienna, after the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) verified that Iran has met all conditions under the nuclear deal.

    The Iran nuclear accord is fragile at its one-year anniversary.

    Upcoming elections in both the U.S. and Iran could yield new leaders determined to derail the deal. The Mideast's wars pit U.S. and Iranian proxies in conflict. Iran's ballistic missiles are threatening American allies in the Middle East. Congressional opposition remains.

    But for now, the seven-nation nuclear pact is holding. Washington and Tehran are expanding cooperation. And Boeing's recent announcement of a multibillion-dollar plane deal with Iran Air suggests some of the agreement's early problems may be getting resolved.

    "It really wasn't long ago that we saw a rapidly expanding nuclear program in Iran, only months away from having enough weapons-grade uranium to build 10 to 12 nuclear weapons, and we were on the cusp of confrontation," Secretary of State John Kerry said recently.

    Trump, Clinton Trade Insults at Dinner

    [NATL-NY] Trump, Clinton Trade Insults at Dinner
    Bitter presidential rivals Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump had one more face-to-face showdown before Election Day. They tried to make it funny but plenty of the jokes bombed, and some even earned scattered boos. Watch each of the candidates' roasts in their entirety here. (Published Friday, Oct. 21, 2016)

    "We have changed the strategic equation."

    One year ago, on July 14, 2015, the United States, six other world powers and Iran finalized almost two years of negotiations on the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action. The pact outlined what Tehran had to do to pull back its nuclear program from the brink of weapons-making capacity. And it spelled out the West's obligations to end many financial, trade and oil sanctions that had battered Iran's economy.

    Iran has lived up to its end of the deal. It shut down thousands of centrifuges for enriching uranium and exported almost its entire stockpile of the bomb-making material. It disabled a heavy water plant that would have produced plutonium usable in a weapon. It opened up its supply chain to far greater scrutiny. An underground enrichment facility near Fordo operates under strict limits.

    If Iran were to race now toward an atomic weapon, the Obama administration and most independent experts say it would need at least a year. The U.S. and its partners — Britain, China, France, Germany and Russia — say that is enough time to discover the effort and intervene. Before the deal was struck, the timeframe for Iran to "break out" toward a bomb was a couple of months.

    Therapy Dogs Provide Comfort in Court

    [NATL-DFW] Therapy Dogs Provide Comfort in Court
    Specially trained dogs are being used to help children and other victims of crimes feel comfortable while taking the witness stand in one California court. (Published Thursday, Oct. 20, 2016)

    Iran's compliance and the expanded breathing room have eliminated for now the threat of a military confrontation.

    In the presidential campaign, discussion about the Iran deal focuses largely on the implications of the agreement and today's limited U.S.-Iranian cooperation, no longer on whether to attack Iran. Presumptive Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton backs the deal; GOP rival Donald Trump has spoken of "renegotiation."

    The situation is uneasy in Iran.

    A year before elections, President Hassan Rouhani is under pressure to show his people the benefits of the agreement. Iran is struggling to attract big investments, with banks and companies fearful of U.S. prosecution or fines.

    June's Boeing announcement, involving dozens of planes and worth as much as $25 billion, could open the floodgates — if it survives challenges from many of the same Republican and Democratic critics who opposed last year's nuclear deal. Last week, the House passed two measures that would block the sale. The Senate hasn't acted yet; if it does, Obama would likely veto the bill.

    But Iranian threats to renege on the deal have the Obama administration on the defensive. It sees Rouhani's success as critical to the accord's survival. To that end, Kerry has lobbied European banks to make greater investments in Iran and U.S. officials even have explored softening financial restrictions on Iran. Such considerations haven't gone over well with Republican critics.

    Obama's Iran outreach is "a textbook example of the failure of appeasement," House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., wrote in a 23-page national security agenda published last month.

    Ballistic missiles pose another test.

    Carl Court/Getty Images

    The U.S. bragged after the deal that it secured a key concession: Prolonging a U.N. ban on Iranian missile development by eight years. Tehran has flaunted the restriction, testing missiles capable of reaching Tel Aviv and bearing "Death to Israel" lettering. It has suffered few repercussions.

    Administration officials say pressures on the nuclear deal make it that much more valuable. Iranian ballistic missiles would be more worrisome if carrying nuclear warheads, the argument goes. Syria's bloody quagmire would be even harder to end if a nuclear-armed Iran were added to the equation.

    "Measured by whether the agreement has prevented Iran from developing or obtaining a nuclear weapon, this deal has so far been successful," said Sen. Chris Coons, a fence-sitting Democrat a year ago who ultimately backed the accord.

    The nuclear deal's future is "highly uncertain," said Ariel Levite at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

    Rescuers Form Human Chain to Save Driver in Burning SUV

    [NATL-LA] Watch: Rescuers Form Human Chain to Save Driver in Burning SUV
    A line of about 12 people formed a human chain on a hillside to rescue a man trapped in a burning sport utility vehicle. The two-vehicle crash happened Sunday Oct. 16, 2016 in Palm Bay, Florida. Smoke billowed from the SUV as rescuers linked arms on a steep embankment and pulled the driver to safety. (Published Tuesday, Oct. 18, 2016)

    He outlined several potential paths forward. But even Iranian compliance poses a threat, because the deal could let Iran start ramping up nuclear activity again after eight years.

    "The clock is steadily ticking — one year down, seven more to go," Levite said.