NJ Men Sue Subway Over Short Footlong Sandwiches

The lawyer of the two men said they had Subway's $5 footlongs measured at 17 different shops and every one came up short

By Geoff Mulvihell
|  Wednesday, Jan 23, 2013  |  Updated 6:15 PM EDT
View Comments (
Chicago Police Rescue Dog Trapped On Ice

Getty Images

Two New Jersey residents are suing Connecticut-based Subway over short footlongs.

Photos and Videos

"Dangerous Dog" Fee Controversy

One New Jersey town is considering a proposal that would increase the fee to have a so-called "dangerous dog" to $700 a year. Brian Thompson reports.

Chicago Police Rescue Dog Trapped On Ice

After two hours trapped on the ice, a dog was rescued by Chicago Police on Jackson Park Harbor. This raw footage shows the final moments of the long rescue on the frozen Lake Michigan harbor.
More Photos and Videos
Related Stories

Two New Jersey men sued Subway this week, claiming the world's biggest fast-food chain has been shorting them by selling so-called footlong sandwiches that measure a bit less than 12 inches.

The suit, filed Tuesday in Superior Court in Mount Holly, may be the first legal filing aimed at the sandwich shops after an embarrassment went viral last week when someone posted a photo of a footlong and a ruler on the company's Facebook page to show that the sandwich was not as long as advertised.

At the time, the company issued a statement saying that the sandwich length can vary a bit when franchises do not bake to the exact corporate standards.

Stephen DeNittis, the lawyer for the plaintiffs in the New Jersey suit, said he's seeking class-action status and is also preparing to file a similar suit in Pennsylvania state court in Philadelphia.

He said he's had sandwiches from 17 shops measured -- and every one came up short.

"The case is about holding companies to deliver what they've promised," he said.

Even though the alleged short of a half-inch or so of bread is relatively small, it adds up, he said. Subway has 38,000 stores around the world, nearly all owned by franchisees and its $5 footlong specials have been a mainstay of the company's ads for five years.

DeNittis said both plaintiffs -- John Farley, of Evesham and Charles Noah Pendrack, of Ocean City -- came to him after reading last week about the short sandwiches.

DeNittis is asking for compensatory damages for his client and a change in Subway's practices.

The Milford, Conn.-based firm should either make sure its sandwiches measure a full foot or stop advertising them as such.

He points to how McDonald's quarter-pounders are advertised as being that weight before they are cooked.

Subway did not immediately return a call to The Associated Press on Wednesday.


Get the latest from NBC10 Philadelphia anytime: Android/iPhone/iPad Apps | SMS Alerts | Twitter | Facebook | Google+ | Instagram | RSS

Get the latest headlines sent to your inbox!
View Comments (
Leave Comments
What's New
10 Questions With
We sit down with some of the... Read more
Follow Us
Sign up to receive news and updates that matter to you.
Send Us Your Story Tips
Check Out